Skip to content
All comparisons

API design tools, compared

Where an OpenAPI file is edited matters less than where it is kept. This page compares API design tools on their editors and on what holds the file afterwards: a Git repository, or the tool's own store.

7 products, compared from their own documentation.

The products, one by one

What each is, its strong points, its limits, and who it suits.

APIGit

A Git-native platform for API design, documentation, mock servers and governance

APIGit keeps every API description as a file in a Git repository it hosts. You edit OpenAPI in a form or as code, see the diff and the rule findings before you commit, and send the change through a pull request. AsyncAPI and GraphQL files sit in the same repository.

Best for:
Teams that want API changes reviewed and versioned the way code is
Price:
Free for one user. Team: $24 a month, 3 seats included; $8 per further seat.

Strong points

  • A real Git repository: clone it, push to it, branch and tag it
  • Form and code views of the same OpenAPI file, with a diff before every commit
  • Pull requests with the governance findings beside the changed files
  • A CLI that lints, scores and finds breaking changes offline

Limits

  • No API client or test runner: it is a design, documentation and mock platform
  • The form editor covers OpenAPI only; AsyncAPI and GraphQL are edited as code

Postman

An API client and testing platform, by Postman, Inc.

Postman's Spec Hub edits OpenAPI in a form or as code and reads a wide range of formats. It grew from the request client, so design sits beside collections, and version control is either Postman's own forks or, with Native Git, a repository you host elsewhere.

Best for:
Teams already in Postman that want the spec next to their collections
Price:
Free for one user. Solo $9 a month and Team $19 per user a month, billed yearly.

Strong points

  • OpenAPI 2.0 to 3.2, AsyncAPI, protobuf, RAML and Smithy
  • Form and code editors
  • Spectral-based rules in the editor and in the CLI
  • Design, client and tests in one app

Limits

  • Not a Git host: Native Git needs a repository on another platform and the desktop app
  • Configurable governance rules are on Enterprise

SwaggerHub

An API design platform, now named Swagger Studio, by SmartBear

SwaggerHub, now Swagger Studio, is the long-standing hosted OpenAPI editor from the company behind the Swagger tools. Definitions live in its registry with versions and reusable domains, and Spectral rule sets check them as you type.

Best for:
Enterprises standardised on SmartBear's suite
Price:
Individual, Team, Enterprise and Enterprise Plus plans; prices are not published.

Strong points

  • Form and code editors with real-time validation
  • Spectral rule sets with their own editor
  • Domains for components shared between APIs
  • Gateway integrations and an on-premise edition

Limits

  • A registry with its own versions: no Git branches or pull requests
  • Git sync pushes one file per version; pulling is Enterprise only
  • No public prices

Stoplight

An API design and documentation platform, by SmartBear

Stoplight made the visual OpenAPI editor popular. Its form editor, JSON Schema models and Spectral style guides sit on top of a Git repository at your own provider, or on Stoplight's storage.

Best for:
Teams that design visually on a repository they already host
Price:
Free for one user and one project. Basic $44 a month billed yearly with three users.

Strong points

  • A visual editor aimed at non-developers
  • Spectral style guides while you edit
  • Works on GitHub, GitLab, Bitbucket and Azure DevOps repositories
  • Public, flat prices

Limits

  • Not a Git host: pull requests and history are on your provider
  • Multi-branch support starts on the Startup plan

Apidog

An all-in-one API design, debugging, testing, mock and documentation platform, by Apidog

Apidog designs APIs in a visual editor inside a project that also holds the requests, mocks and tests, so a schema change reaches all of them. Versioning is Apidog's own: sprint branches merged into a protected main branch.

Best for:
Teams that want design and testing in one workspace
Price:
Free for up to four users. Basic from $9 per user a month.

Strong points

  • A visual editor that needs no YAML
  • Design feeds debugging, mocks and tests in the same project
  • Free for up to four users
  • On-premises and EU deployments

Limits

  • The project lives in Apidog's store; Git sync is a beta Spec-first mode
  • Its own guidelines and AI check rather than Spectral rules, and no documented breaking-change check

Redocly

An API documentation platform, with the open-source Redoc and Redocly CLI, by Redocly Inc.

Redocly approaches design from the repository: you write OpenAPI as code, in your editor or in its web editor, and Redocly CLI lints, bundles and splits the files. Review happens in pull requests with a visual diff.

Best for:
Engineering teams that write OpenAPI by hand in their own repository
Price:
No free hosted plan. Pro $249 a month billed yearly, unlimited seats. Redoc and Redocly CLI are free and open source.

Strong points

  • Git branches and pull requests with previews and line comments
  • An open-source CLI with configurable rules
  • OpenAPI 3.2, AsyncAPI, GraphQL and Arazzo

Limits

  • No visual or form editor for OpenAPI
  • No free hosted plan

Insomnia

An open-source API client with a spec editor, by Kong

Insomnia is first an API client, with a Spec tab that edits an OpenAPI file as code beside a live preview, lints it with Spectral and generates requests from it. With Git Sync the file lives in your own repository.

Best for:
Developers who want the spec next to the requests that exercise it
Price:
Free Essentials plan. Pro $12 per user a month.

Strong points

  • Spectral linting in the editor and in the inso CLI, with custom rules
  • Requests generated from the spec, in the same app
  • Local, cloud or Git storage for each project
  • Open source, with a free plan for teams

Limits

  • A code editor only: no form editor
  • No pull requests or hosted documentation; Git Sync needs a repository on another host

Side by side

Each product name opens its full comparison with APIGit.

FeatureAPIGitPostmanSwaggerHubStoplightApidogRedoclyInsomnia
Git and version control
Where your API files liveYes:Its own Git repositoryPartly:Postman Cloud, or your repoNo:Its own registryPartly:Your repo, or StoplightPartly:Its own project storeYes:Your repo, or Redocly'sPartly:Device, cloud or your repo
Clone and push with any Git clientYes:HTTPS and SSHNo:Not a Git hostNo:Not a Git hostNo:Through your Git hostNo:Not a Git hostPartly:Through your Git hostNo:Not a Git host
Branches and tagsYes:Git branchesPartly:Forks; Git via your repoNo:Its own versionsYes:Git branches, paidPartly:Its own sprint branchesYes:Git branchesYes:Git, via your repo
Pull requests and reviewYes:Built inPartly:On forked collectionsPartly:Comments, no PRsPartly:On your Git hostPartly:Its own merge requestsYes:Built in, with previewsNo:On your Git host
Commit history and diffYes:Every commitPartly:Diff in its pull requestsPartly:Version comparePartly:On your Git hostPartly:Per endpointPartly:Diff; partial historyPartly:Commit and push
Working with GitHub, GitLab and othersYes:Optional syncYes:Native GitPartly:Push; pull on EnterpriseYes:Four providersPartly:Spec-first mode, betaYes:Four providersYes:Git Sync
API design
OpenAPI versionsYes:2.0, 3.0, 3.1Yes:2.0 to 3.2Yes:2.0 to 3.1Yes:2.0, 3.0, 3.1Yes:2.0, 3.0, 3.1Yes:2.0 to 3.2Yes:2.0 and later
Visual editor for OpenAPIYes:Form and codeYes:Form and codeYes:Form and codeYes:Form and codeYes:Visual editorNo:Code editor onlyPartly:Code editor, preview
AsyncAPI and GraphQLYes:BothYes:Both, and morePartly:AsyncAPIPartly:JSON SchemaPartly:GraphQL; no AsyncAPIYes:Both, and morePartly:As requests
Governance
Style rules for API descriptionsYes:Spectral rule setsYes:Spectral-basedYes:Spectral rule setsYes:Spectral style guidesPartly:Own guidelines, AI checkYes:Redocly CLI rulesYes:Spectral
Breaking-change checkYes:CLI, in CINot coveredPartly:Via contract testingNo:Not documentedNo:Not documentedPartly:ExperimentalNo:Not documented
  • Yes:Has it
  • Partly:Has part of it; the cell says which
  • No:Does not have it

Scroll sideways for every product.

How to choose

Start from where the file lives

If the spec should be reviewed like code, pick a tool that keeps it in Git rather than one that exports to Git.

Check who edits

A form editor lets product owners and testers change a spec. A code editor and a CLI suit engineers and coding agents. Many teams need both on the same file.

Put the rules in the pipeline

Style rules that only show in an editor are advice. Look for the same rules as a check in CI.

Questions

Which API design tools were compared?
APIGit, Postman, SwaggerHub, Stoplight, Apidog, Redocly and Insomnia. They were chosen because teams that work with OpenAPI most often weigh them against each other. The page is published by APIGit, so APIGit is listed first; the limits of each product, ours included, are listed beside its strong points.
Where do the facts come from?
From each vendor's own public documentation and pricing pages, listed under the table with the date they were read. APIGit's entries follow our documentation and pricing page.
Why does the comparison start with Git?
Because an API description is a file that several people change, and Git is the tool built for that. A tool that keeps the file in a real Git repository gives you branches, review and history without a sync step; a tool with its own store has to rebuild those things or copy the file out.
Can I use more than one of these tools?
Yes, and many teams do. Because an APIGit project is an ordinary Git repository, any tool that reads OpenAPI files from Git or from a folder on your machine can work with the same files.

Other jobs: API documentation tools, API mocking tools.

Try it yourself

Worked examples from the learn hub, each with the output of the tools.

Put your API and docs in a repository today

Create a free workspace, add an OpenAPI file and a Markdown guide, and publish your first documentation site and mock server in minutes.

Free for individuals. No credit card.

$ npm install -g @apigit/cli$ apigit auth login$ apigit doc publish